The median 2014 Cayman in the Canadian market sits at $59,850. That's your anchor. If a car is priced anywhere near it with typical mileage, you're paying a fair number, not a memorable one.
Most listings land between $53,984 and $62,000. That's a tight band, only about $8,000 wide, which tells you sellers agree on what this car is worth. A price under $54,000 is worth a hard look at why. Above $62,000 you're paying for something specific, so make the seller justify it.
What the mileage tells you
Median distance on these cars is 64,000 km. A decade in, that works out to roughly 6,400 km a year, which is light use for a sports car. If the one you're eyeing is sitting well under 64,000, that's a genuine point in its favour and a reason it might push toward the top of the range.
The move here is simple. Use $59,850 as your line in the sand, adjust for how the odometer compares to 64,000 km, and let the $54K-$62K range tell you when a listing has drifted off market.
Numbers reflect live listings across Canada over the last 90 days, filtered for outliers. Data as of . Prices in CAD.