The median 2006 Cayman in the Canadian market sits at $33,350. That's your anchor. Pay much above it and you'd want a real reason, whether that's low kilometres, fresh service records, or a rare colour someone's chasing.
Most of these cars land between $28,975 and $34,349. So the spread is fairly tight, only about $5,400 from the low end of typical to the high end. A car near $29K isn't a fixer and a car near $34K isn't a unicorn. They're both normal for this year, and where a specific example falls usually comes down to condition and history more than anything.
What the numbers tell a buyer
Median mileage runs 103,514 km. If the car you're eyeing has clocked meaningfully more than that, use it as leverage. Less than that, expect the seller to lean on it and price closer to the top of the range.
We've flagged 3 deals on this model year in the last 90 days. Not a flood. So if something priced under $29K shows up in clean shape, it won't sit around waiting for you to think it over.
Bottom line for a buyer: treat $33,350 as fair, anything under $29K as worth a hard look, and above $34,349 as a car that needs to justify the premium with paperwork or kilometres.
Numbers reflect live listings across Canada over the last 90 days, filtered for outliers. Data as of . Prices in CAD.