The median price on a 2009 Honda Fit right now sits at $4,677. That's your anchor. If a seller is asking near that number for a car with average wear, you're in fair territory.
Most of the market falls between $3,744 and $7,647. That $3,900 spread is wide for a car at this price point, and it tells you condition and history are doing most of the work. A Fit near the bottom of the range is usually higher-km or needs something. Toward the top, you're paying for a cleaner, better-kept example.
What to actually pay
The typical 2009 Fit on the Canadian market has about 211,700 km on it. So when you're reading a listing, that's the mileage baseline to judge against. Well under it, the higher end of the range starts to make sense. Well over it, anything near the top gets hard to justify.
We've flagged 5 deals on this model year in the last 90 days. Not a flood, but enough that a patient buyer working live Canadian listings can find one priced below the $4,677 median rather than chasing the top of the range.
Bottom line: use $4,677 as your reference, treat anything under $3,744 as a car you need to inspect hard, and be skeptical of asks near $7,647 unless the km and condition clearly back it up.
Numbers reflect live listings across Canada over the last 90 days, filtered for outliers. Data as of . Prices in CAD.